P52 vs P58: luxury is no easy choice

When we saw them at the last Cannes Yachting Festival at their debut, we had no doubt: the P52 and P58, the two latest gems from Fiart, are both absolutely stunning. Resulting from the new collaboration with architect Stefano Pastrovich, the two models in the newly launched P line are a pure blend of design, elegance, and performance—and they completely won us over. Not only are they incredibly captivating, but the P52 and P58 handle the sea beautifully, offering extraordinary capabilities. These boats represent a radically different concept from anything we’ve seen so far in the yachting world.

The only “problem”—if we can call it that—is this: which one to choose? An owner facing this dilemma would have a lot to think about. Both models boast impeccable aesthetics and extraordinary performance. The Naples-based shipyard has meticulously designed every detail, making the most of every space to ensure both conviviality and privacy, comfort and performance. Let’s be clear: neither one outshines the other, because they’re both virtually perfect. What we aim to highlight are their common features and differences, allowing for a comparison that brings out the unique qualities of each model.

P52 vs P58: design, layout and liveability

The P52 and P58 share a modern and refined look, with sleek lines and smooth surfaces that express both dynamism and elegance. Naturally, the first big difference lies in the size: the P52 is 15.93 metres long, while the P58 stretches to 17.76 metres. As such, the P52 might be an ideal entry point for owners new to this segment, while the P58 stands as the flagship of the range—perfect for those seeking the best and who want more space and greater customisation options. That said, it’s worth noting that despite its smaller size, the P52 doesn’t lack a thing: it’s more compact but still includes all the comforts of the bigger model.

In terms of layout, the P52 offers two spacious cabins and a central living area, ideal for cruising with family or friends. The fully equipped outdoor galley and large sunbathing areas at the bow and stern ensure excellent use of outdoor space.

The P58 stands out for the modularity of its interiors: owners can choose between two main layouts, both featuring two master cabins with en-suite bathrooms and a living area with galley and salon. The interior headroom, over 3 metres, and the presence of skylights give the spaces a bright and airy feel.

Performance and Range

For those who prioritise navigation performance, it’s worth noting what both models have to offer. The more compact P52, powered by two Volvo IPS800 engines, reaches a top speed of 35 knots and has a range of approximately 300 nautical miles. The P58, equipped with twin Volvo IPS950 engines, offers similar top speeds but extends the range to 450 nautical miles, thanks to its larger fuel tank.

Anyone interested in a deeper dive into performance can read our sea trial review of the Fiart P52.

So, which one to choose?

The choice between the P52 and P58 comes down to the owner’s needs. The P52 is ideal for those seeking a compact yet complete yacht, perfect for coastal cruising and short stays. The P58, on the other hand, is the perfect option for those who want more space, greater range, and the option to customize the interiors—making it suitable for longer cruises and an even more luxurious onboard experience. In either case, you can’t go wrong: with the P52 and P58, Fiart offers two flawless yachts that combine design, comfort, and performance like never before.